Open Season Is Here: A Step-by-Step Plan Comparison Checklist
Open Season arrives November 9th and runs through December 14th. If you did the prep work I’ve been recommending over the past several weeks, it’s time for it to pay off. You’ve got your spending history, your prescription list, and your known needs for next year. Now it’s time to actually compare plans and make your election. This is the checklist I use myself, and it turns what feels like an overwhelming decision into a series of manageable steps.
This is especially important this year because FEHB premiums are increasing at an average of 10.9% for 2027, the third year in a row with double-digit increases! The PSHB plans are increasing their premiums by an average of 8.2%.
Don’t rush this, but don’t put it off either. The worst outcome is running out the clock and letting your enrollment roll over by default. Let’s walk through it methodically.
Step One: Start With Your Actual Costs, Not the Premium
I’ll keep hammering this because it’s the foundation of a good decision: the premium is only part of your cost. Pull out the total out-of-pocket spending number you assembled during your prep: deductibles, copays, coinsurance, and prescriptions from the past year. Your goal is to estimate your total annual cost under each plan you’re considering, which is premiums plus your realistic expected out-of-pocket spending. A plan with a higher premium can easily be the cheaper choice overall if it has a lower deductible and better cost-sharing for the care your family actually uses.
Step Two: Check Every Prescription Against the Formulary
Take your list of regular medications and check each one against the formulary of every plan you’re seriously considering. A drug that’s inexpensive on your current plan can move to a higher tier, require prior authorization, or be excluded entirely on another plan. For anyone taking specialty or brand-name medications, this single step can decide between two plans, so don’t skip it.
Step Three: Confirm Your Doctors and Hospitals Are In-Network
If you have doctors, specialists, or a hospital system you want to keep, verify they’re in-network for any plan you’re considering. Networks change year to year, and even if you stay with your current plan, it doesn’t guarantee your providers will still participate. A few minutes spent confirming this now can save you an unpleasant, expensive surprise in the middle of next year.
Step Four: Factor in Your Medicare Coordination
If you or your spouse are Medicare-eligible, look specifically at how each plan coordinates with Medicare. This is covered in Section 9 of all plan brochures. Does it waive or reduce cost-sharing for members with Part B? Does it offer a Part B premium reimbursement? How does its prescription coverage work alongside Medicare? For Medicare-eligible retirees, these coordination features often matter more than the base premium, and they vary significantly by plan.
Step Five: Account for Life Changes in the Coming Year
Layer in anything you know is coming next year. A planned surgery, a new diagnosis, a pregnancy, a child aging off your coverage at 26, or a spouse retiring or becoming Medicare-eligible – any of these changes can make one plan make more sense. The best plan for your situation this year may not be the best plan for where you’ll actually be next year.
Step Six: Coordinate Your Dental, Vision, and FSA Elections
Remember that Open Season is more than FEHB. Review your FEDVIP dental and vision coverage, and decide on your Flexible Spending Account contribution for next year. If you’re anticipating significant dental or vision expenses, that affects both your FEDVIP choice and how much to set aside pre-tax in an FSA. Make these decisions together, not as separate afterthoughts.
Step Seven: Make Your Election Early, Then Confirm It
Once you’ve settled on your plan, make your election with time to spare, not on the final day. Then, and this is the step people skip, confirm that your election was actually recorded. Log back in and verify, or check for a confirmation. I’ve heard from too many people who thought they’d made a change only to discover in January that it never went through. Never assume, always confirm.
A Note for Those Tempted to Do Nothing
If you’re happy with your current plan and thinking about just letting it roll over, I’d still urge you to run through at least the first three steps. Plans change their benefits, formularies, and networks every year, even when you stay put. Confirming your current plan still serves you well is a legitimate decision. Letting it roll over without checking is not a decision; it’s a gamble, and it’s the one that most often costs federal families money.
Federal Employees Face Another Double-Digit FEHB Premium Increase in 2027
The Bottom Line
A good Open Season decision isn’t about finding the plan with the lowest premium; it’s about finding the plan with the lowest total cost for the care your family actually uses, with the providers you want, the prescriptions you take, and the Medicare coordination that fits your situation. Work through these steps in order, coordinate your dental, vision, and FSA choices, make your election early, and confirm it went through. Do that, and you’ll head into next year knowing you made a deliberate, money-smart choice rather than a default one.
Last 5 posts by Dennis Damp
- PSHB for Postal Retirees: Medicare, Plans & Open Season - November 7th, 2026
- Fixed Income Investments: A 2026 Guide for Retirees - November 4th, 2026
- Medicare Annual Enrollment Period: FEHB & PSHB Guides - October 24th, 2026
- 2027 COLA Announcement: What It Means for Your Annuity - October 21st, 2026
- Federal Benefits Changes: What Federal Employees Should Know - October 17th, 2026

Dennis V. Damp is an author, retired federal manager, business owner, career counselor and veteran. Damp is the author of 28 books, a recognized benefits expert, and a retired federal manager with 35 years’ service. Dennis has been a guest on hundreds of radio talk shows, CNN’s YOUR MONEY and the Lou Dobbs Cable TV shows, lectured at universities and colleges, produced Internet web sites and training videos, and has written hundreds of articles for national magazines and newspapers. His books have been featured in the Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, New York Times and U.S. News & World Report.
Dennis joined the Air Force in 1968 and spent over three years on active duty and an additional seven years with the Air National Guard. He was hired by the Department of Defense (DOD) after leaving active duty and transferred to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) in 1975. He spent the remainder of his career in various positions with the FAA. His last position was technical operations manager at the Pittsburgh International Airport’s air traffic control tower.









